Novel: The Fellowship of the Ring [Lord of the Rings #1]

Author: J. R. R. Tolkien, 1954
Genre: Fantasy
Format: Ebook, 480 pages

I don’t know what it is about Tolkien, but every time I have to write about him I stumble and find myself at a loss for words. Same very thing happened a couple of years ago when I read The Hobbit. I ended up never writing anything. What a waste on my behalf, because reading Tolkien for the first time is a unique experience many would kill to experience one more time. Well, maybe not kill, but trip every newbie in a fit of raging jealousy. Now I don’t remember much about my first feelings about the book and it really sucks. What I remember though is convincing myself that reading The Lord of the Rings without getting to know the prequel must be sacrilege. I guess it was my excuse for avoiding the intimidating mammoth. This year I finally realized that with having The Hobbit in my “finished” pile means I cannot avoid its big brother anymore. And so my journey began.

The Fellowship of the Ring opens on a rather lighthearted note, similar to that of The Hobbit, with Bilbo arranging for his nephew Frodo to take over the Bag End after leaving for a new journey of self-discovery. I chuckled out loud and delightfully re-read favorite passages, taking little notes about the curiosities and quirkiness of hobbits. Things progressed at a good pace, and soon we saw Gandalf making his entrance. One major thing that bugs me about the typical fantasy staple of a wizard showing up to instruct a commoner/nobody to go on a life-changing quest for fortune and glory is that I keep wondering why this so-called all-powerful wizard cannot go and do the quest himself. After all, with all the abra kadabra up his sleeve, he probably stands a better chance to get to the destination in one piece. But no, Galdalf is afraid that the power of the ring might prove too much for him, so he sends others on this insane ride. So far, Gandalf is not impressing me.

First we learn that strange Black Riders are following the company and I have to say they are pretty awesome! Did anyone else get the creeps when Frodo described his pursuers sniffing the air like hounds on the hunt? Or bit their nails as they approached the travelers’ campfire and waited in the shadows for a perfect opportunity to attack? Who cares about Sauron, these guys have the evil menace nailed down to perfection! Next, there is of course the dwarf city in the mines of Moria overrun by brute Orcs and the fiery Balrog. The company’s journey in the dark mines was almost as gripping as the Black Riders’ hunt, especially with the strange creature lurking in the depth of the lake, trying to drown everyone coming close to the gates of Moria. Finally, there is the sneaky Gollum forever lusting after his precious ring. Though he’s not even remotely as scary as the previously mentioned enemies of Frodo, I did enjoy his somewhat comical vengeance attempts against his ever-hated Bagginses. Overall, Tolkien did a great job with his antagonists, so I only hope the following books will maintain the trend.

What I didn’t really like about the book is Tolkien’s insistence on describing everything as deadly and unapproachable, all while his characters plow through the said settings unharmed and well. He keeps saying things like, Look at that Elven forest, nobody has ever crossed it in one piece! Or, Look at the ancient mines of Moria, nobody has ever found their way out of them alive! Yet, tam-taddam-tam, a bunch of homebody hobbits manage to travel through with no major injuries. And don’t try to convince me that Gandalf didn’t survive the battle in the first book, because we all know that by the laws of fantasy novels he must emerge in the next volume and save the heroes at a critical point! That is probably the only thing I did not enjoy about The Fellowship of the Ring – I always knew that everything will be alright. Maybe I am being spoiled by George R. R. Martin and his obsession with killing off major characters for no reason. I am expecting some major drama come the next book, so hopefully things improve in the predictability department.


  1. I completely agree with you about the Black Riders. When I read the books, to me they were the perfect embodiment of fear. I was disappointed by them in the movies, I think because no actual image on a screen could be as frightening as the Black Riders were in my head. It’s interesting to hear that you had a similar response to the Black Riders as an adult. I read LotR when I was fairly young, so I don’t know how much my fear of the Black Riders was a function of my age.

  2. It might sound weird, but I have never watched the movies (I don’t know if I ever will). And I know that reading LotR for the first time as an adult must be a different experience compared to a child’s impression. Tolkien appealed to me on many different levels, though I have to admit I regret not being able to have those memories. Call me impressionable, but some parts of The Fellowship were pretty spooky and I don’t know if my age did anything to subdue them. 🙂

  3. I think it is perfectly reasonable not to watch the movies. I enjoyed them, but I did seriously consider avoiding them. It makes me a bit sad that we all used to have our own unique mental images of the people and places but these are now more homogenized by so many people having seen the images from the movies.

  4. That’s the thing about watching movies before reading books. You just keep imagining the actors instead of characters. I did end up seeing Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn in my head, but others were products of my own imagination.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: